
I am late to Amazon's The Man in the High Castle (1),
which ended its four-season run in 2019. I began watching it partly to spot
locations in Vancouver, my hometown, where much of the series was filmed. One of the locations seen frequently mattered more to me than the others. Since high school, I have admired
Arthur Erickson's MacMillan Bloedel Building, now named Arthur Erickson Place. I
recognized it immediately.
In the series, it is the headquarters of the Greater Nazi
Reich, looming over Manhattan from the site of the United Nations. The building
has had supporting roles in productions from The X-Files
to Deadpool, but never one this prominent.
The producers did not use it as built. They stretched it
digitally until it dwarfed every tower on the skyline, draped a swastika banner
down its face, and crowned it with an eagle. A visual effects producer told the
New York Times that the team made sure in every shot that it was the
tallest building, "to make it look menacing and imposing" (Egner, 2015). In April 2015, the crew filmed at 1075 West Georgia Street and hung an actual red
banner on Erickson's facade, adding the swastika later in post-production.
For at least one afternoon, the Reich's red banner hung on a building I had
admired for decades.
My copy of "The Architecture of Arthur Erickson."
Erickson was my idea of what an architect could be. One of
the first architecture books I bought was The Architecture of Arthur
Erickson (Tundra Books, 1975), in which Erickson described MacMillan
Bloedel as "my 'Doric' building, uncompromising in its simplicity." I
understood what he meant, or believed I did. Its mass was the point: solid
concrete walls pierced by deep-set square windows. It was unlike both the glass
lightness of its contemporary, the Guinness Tower, and the stone, brick, and
terra cotta of the Marine Building and the Hotel Vancouver. To a teenager
hungry for architectural conviction, it represented a third way.
The MacMillan Bloedel Building, now Arthur Erickson
Place, from the base looking up (my photo).
Rereading Erickson's account now, I am struck by how
humane, even traditional, his reasoning was. He disliked the impermanence of
the modern office building, with its hung ceilings, movable partitions, and
curtain walls. People spent most of their working lives in these buildings, he
argued, and deserved a sense of stability. He proposed solid bearing walls
instead, "returning to the oldest and most traditional of
techniques." The walls taper from ten feet thick at the base to one foot
at the top. Erickson insisted that the concrete be cast in place, with the pour
lines left visible as patina. Yet the reasoning behind these choices is
invisible from West Georgia Street, and entirely invisible on a television
screen.
Would I admire MacMillan Bloedel had I never read
Erickson's explanation of it? Perhaps not.
I encountered the building and Erickson's description of it at
roughly the same time. I do not know whether I first loved the building and
then embraced Erickson's explanation, or whether the explanation taught me what
to love. Long before I designed anything myself, I learned to see the MacMillan
Bloedel Building through the architect's eyes. To me, the exposed concrete spoke of
permanence because Erickson said permanence was the point. I knew about the
tapering bearing walls, the cast-in-place construction, and the rejection of
the disposable office tower. The building's meaning, as I understood it, was
inseparable from the argument Erickson made for it.
Environmental psychologist Robert Gifford and his
colleagues documented differences in how architects and laypersons judge
buildings (Gifford et al., 2000), while Brown and Gifford later found
that architects were poor predictors of public reactions, in part because their
own conceptual criteria shaped their judgments (Brown
and Gifford, 2001). MacMillan Bloedel is a case in point. Erickson's
biographer, David Stouck, notes that Vancouverites have both admired and
scorned it, and seen through the lens of The Man in the High Castle, I
understand why. A massive concrete slab stripped of ornament is not far removed
from the visual vocabulary filmmakers use to signify power without warmth.
Erickson intended permanence and dignity; others see severity. Both readings
arise from the same forms.
My admiration for Erickson's other great Vancouver works
rests on firmer ground. He described Simon Fraser University as a sequence of
experiences, a climb through forest and up sets of stairs to a quadrangle at the
summit. He made the quadrangle's facade "sufficiently monotonous" so
that the sky, the views, and the garden would command attention. Visitors saw
echoes of Machu Picchu, Fatehpur Sikri, and Monte Albán in the terraced campus. The raw
concrete seemed to belong on the mountaintop, where it suggested permanence and
great age.
Erickson described the Museum of Anthropology's Great Hall
in Doric terms, too, invoking the early temples at Athens and Paestum and a
monumental serenity that combined power and grace. Notably, Erickson chose to build atop abandoned World War II gun
emplacements on the Point Grey cliffs, and one gun mount now serves as the
pedestal for Bill Reid's The Raven and the First Men. The museum, built
over military foundations, reads as a sanctuary, whereas in The Man in the High Castle, the corporate
office tower becomes the Reich.
The Museum Of Anthropology Great Hall (my photo)
These buildings do not rely on concrete alone. At Simon
Fraser, architecture works in concert with forest, sky, and distance. At Point
Grey, the sea, the landscape, and the carvings all contribute to the
experience. The carvings, in particular, reward close attention, down to the
marks of the adze. The MacMillan Bloedel Building offers little of this; its concrete and glass carry almost the entire visual
burden.
In A Theory of Architecture (2006), Nikos Salingaros
describes how traditional buildings nest a hierarchy of scales, from overall
massing down through windows, panes, columns, trim, and surface texture.
MacMillan Bloedel has the largest and smallest of these but largely omits the
middle, by design. Erickson specified mullionless seven-foot panes so that
nothing would interrupt the contrast of concrete and glass. Greek Doric columns
had capitals and flutes. Erickson's Doric was the idea of Doric, stripped of
the features that gave the order its texture.
Yet for The Man in the High Castle, the building did not become a symbol of the Reich unaided. Its
forms made that reading possible, but the producers had to finish the job. They
added height, a banner, an eagle, and a neoclassical forecourt, giving the
altered building more levels of detail than Erickson's original and far more
explicit historical associations.(2) They even compressed Cass Gilbert's Gothic Woolworth Building so the headquarters could dominate it. In 1988, Erickson wrote that his building had become
"somewhat tucked away" among taller towers "of a more florid,
Corinthian taste." The series reversed that arrangement, setting his Doric
slab above Manhattan's most ornate towers and turning Erickson's restraint into
a sign of oppression.
None of this persuades me to recant. I can admire a
building because I understand its argument, even if that is not how most people
encounter it. Erickson himself acknowledged that visitors found meanings in his
work he never intended. The Man in the High Castle makes that gap hard
to ignore. How much of a building's meaning
should depend on explanation?
I bought Erickson's monograph as a teenager, and its
account of the MacMillan Bloedel Building became part of how I interpreted its architecture. The
next time I stand on West Georgia Street looking up at those tapering walls, I
expect I will still see what Erickson taught me to see. I am less sure that I
will see only that.
(1) For the record, I like the series. It's a slow-burn
thriller with handsome production design and fine performances from its
antagonists, though I find the resistance characters flat and the hushed
dialogue often hard to hear. Spotting Vancouver locations, many familiar from
my youth, remains an amusing distraction.
(2) The architecture of the actual Third Reich, Albert Speer's stripped classicism, retained cornices, colonnades, and a clear
hierarchy of scale. Hierarchical scaling may explain why a building feels
coherent; it does not guarantee that it feels kind.
No comments:
Post a Comment